Beyond the Backlog

In my long career as a product professional, I’ve witnessed firsthand the ever-evolving landscape of product development and market competition. In this constant chess game of product launches and market positioning, I’ve found an unexpected ally: game theory. Today, I’m excited to share with you how this powerful framework can revolutionize your approach to competitive product positioning.

---

---

Introduction

Staying ahead of the competition isn’t just an advantage—it’s a necessity. We’re constantly seeking new tools and strategies to give our products the edge they need to succeed. But what if I told you that one of the most powerful tools at our disposal has been around for decades, hiding in plain sight?

Enter game theory.

You might be thinking, “Game theory? Isn’t that something economists use?” And you’d be right—but it’s so much more than that. Game theory, at its core, is about strategic decision-making in competitive situations. Sound familiar? That’s exactly what we do every day as product managers.

In this post, I’m going to take you on a journey through the fascinating world of game theory and show you how it can be applied to competitive product positioning. We’ll explore real-world examples, discuss practical strategies, and even peek into the future of this approach. By the end, you’ll have a new perspective on product strategy that could change the way you approach competition forever.

Understanding Game Theory

Before we can apply game theory to our product strategies, we need to understand what it is and how it works. Don’t worry—I promise this won’t feel like a dry economics lecture.

What is Game Theory?

At its simplest, game theory is a framework for understanding how decisions are made in situations where the outcome depends not just on your own choices, but on the choices of others as well. It’s called “game” theory because it was initially used to analyze parlor games like poker or chess. But don’t let the name fool you—this is serious business.

In the context of product management, we can think of the “game” as the competitive market landscape, where each company’s moves affect the others’ outcomes. Your product launch isn’t happening in a vacuum; it’s part of a complex ecosystem of competitor actions, customer preferences, and market trends.

Key Concepts in Game Theory

To use game theory effectively, there are a few key concepts we need to grasp:

1. Players: In our case, these are the companies or products in the competitive landscape.
2. Strategies: The actions each player can take. For us, this might be pricing decisions, feature sets, or marketing approaches.
3. Payoffs: The outcomes or rewards for each combination of strategies. In product management, this could be market share, revenue, or customer acquisition.
4. Nash Equilibrium: A stable state where no player can gain an advantage by changing their strategy unilaterally. This is crucial for understanding sustainable competitive positions.
5. Zero-sum vs. Non-zero-sum Games: In a zero-sum game, one player’s gain is another’s loss. Many market situations are actually non-zero-sum, where cooperation can lead to better outcomes for all players.

Why Game Theory Matters for Product Managers

You might be wondering, “This all sounds interesting, but why should I care as a product manager?” Great question! Here’s why I believe game theory is invaluable in our field:

1. Strategic Foresight: Game theory helps us anticipate competitor actions and plan our responses accordingly.
2. Decision Framework: It provides a structured way to analyze complex competitive situations and make more informed decisions.
3. Risk Management: By considering multiple scenarios and outcomes, we can better manage risks in our product strategies.
4. Competitive Advantage: Understanding game theory can give you an edge in positioning your product effectively against competitors.
5. Collaboration Opportunities: It can help identify situations where cooperation might be more beneficial than pure competition.

As we move forward, keep these concepts in mind. They’ll form the foundation of our approach to competitive product positioning.

The Basics of Competitive Product Positioning

Now that we’ve got a handle on game theory, let’s talk about competitive product positioning. As product managers, this is something we deal with every day, often without even realizing it.

What is Competitive Product Positioning?

Competitive product positioning is the art and science of defining how your product stands out in the market. It’s about carving out a unique space in the customer’s mind that differentiates your offering from the competition.

In my early days as a product manager, positioning was just about having better features or a lower price. But I quickly learned it’s so much more nuanced than that. It’s about understanding your customers’ needs, your competitors’ strengths and weaknesses, and finding that sweet spot where your product can shine.

Key Elements of Product Positioning

In my experience, effective product positioning boils down to a few key elements:

1. Target Market: Who are you serving? Understanding your audience is crucial.
2. Unique Value Proposition: What makes your product special? This needs to be clear and compelling.
3. Competitive Landscape: Who are you up against? Knowing your competitors inside and out is essential.
4. Product Benefits: What problems does your product solve? Focus on outcomes, not just features.
5. Brand Personality: How does your product make customers feel? This emotional connection can be a powerful differentiator.

The Positioning Process

Over the years, I’ve developed a process for positioning that has served me well:

1. Market Research: Start by thoroughly understanding your market and customers.
2. Competitor Analysis: Study your competitors’ positioning strategies.
3. Identify Gaps: Look for unmet needs or underserved segments in the market.
4. Define Your Position: Based on your research, determine where your product fits best.
5. Test and Refine: Your initial positioning might not be perfect. Be prepared to iterate based on market feedback.

Why Competitive Positioning Matters

Having a great product isn’t enough. You need to ensure that your target customers understand why your product is the best choice for them. Effective positioning:

• Helps customers quickly understand your product’s value
• Guides your product development and marketing efforts
• Differentiates you from competitors
• Can justify premium pricing if done correctly

Now, here’s where things get really interesting. When we combine this understanding of competitive positioning with the principles of game theory we discussed earlier, we open up a whole new world of strategic possibilities.

In the next section, we’ll explore how game theory can be applied to make our competitive positioning strategies more robust and effective.

---

Subscribe and never miss another post:

---

Applying Game Theory to Product Positioning

Now, this is where things get exciting. As a product manager, I’ve found that applying game theory to product positioning can be a game-changer (pun intended). Let’s dive into how we can use game theory principles to supercharge our positioning strategies.

The Product Positioning Game

First, let’s frame competitive product positioning as a game:

• Players: Your company and your competitors
• Strategies: Different positioning options (e.g., premium quality, low cost, innovative features)
• Payoffs: Market share, revenue, customer loyalty

Game Theory Strategies in Positioning

1. Dominant Strategy: In game theory, a dominant strategy is one that produces the best outcome for a player regardless of what other players do. In product positioning, this might be a unique feature or capability that your competitors can’t easily replicate. Personal Example: I once worked on a project management tool that had unparalleled integration capabilities. We made this our dominant strategy in positioning, emphasizing it regardless of competitors’ moves.
2. Nash Equilibrium: This is a state where each player is making the best decision for themselves, given what others are doing. In positioning, it’s about finding a stable market position. Real-world Example: Think about the equilibrium between Coca-Cola and Pepsi. They’ve settled into distinct brand identities that have remained stable for years.
3. Prisoner’s Dilemma: This classic game theory scenario can apply to pricing strategies. Companies might be tempted to engage in a price war, but cooperation (maintaining higher prices) could benefit everyone. Industry Example: We’ve seen this play out in the airline industry, where price matching often leads to reduced profits for all players.
4. Sequential Games: In these games, players take turns making moves. This applies when you’re entering a market with established players or when a competitor is responding to your positioning. Strategy Tip: Always think several moves ahead. How will competitors likely respond to your positioning, and how will you counter?
5. Signaling: This involves conveying information about your product’s quality or your company’s intentions through your actions. Example: A long warranty period can signal confidence in product quality.

Practical Application: The Positioning Matrix

One tool I’ve found incredibly useful is creating a game theory-inspired positioning matrix. Here’s how to do it:

1. List your top competitors across the top of a grid.
2. Down the side, list potential positioning strategies.
3. In each cell, estimate the outcome (market share, revenue) if you and a competitor both chose that strategy.
4. Use this to identify your best positioning options and potential competitor responses.

Real-world Examples

Let’s look at some real-world examples of game theory in action in product positioning:

Apple vs. Samsung

The smartphone market provides a classic example of game theory in product positioning:

• Apple’s Move: Positioned as a premium, innovative brand with a closed ecosystem.
• Samsung’s Counter: Offered a wider range of products at various price points, emphasizing customization and openness.

The Game Theory Angle: This is a great example of differentiation in a non-zero-sum game. Both companies have found unique positions that allow them to thrive simultaneously.

Netflix’s Streaming Pivot

Netflix’s transition from DVD rentals to streaming is a masterclass in anticipating competitor moves:

• Initial Position: Convenient DVD rentals by mail.
• Strategic Move: Early investment in streaming technology.
• Competitor Response: Traditional media companies were slow to react, giving Netflix a first-mover advantage.

The Game Theory Angle: Netflix played a sequential game, making the first move into streaming and forcing competitors to play catch-up.

Amazon’s Long-Term Strategy

Amazon’s willingness to forgo short-term profits for long-term market dominance is a perfect example of far-sighted game theory application:

• Strategy: Prioritize growth and market share over immediate profitability.
• Competitor Impact: Many competitors couldn’t sustain the low margins, leading to Amazon’s market dominance.

The Game Theory Angle: Amazon essentially changed the rules of the game, focusing on a payoff (market share) different from that of traditional retailers (short-term profits).

Strategies and Tactics

Now that we’ve seen how game theory applies to product positioning let’s discuss some strategies and tactics you can use:

1. Always Consider the Long Game

Don’t just think about your next move; consider how the competitive landscape might evolve over time.

Tip: Create multiple future scenarios and plan your positioning strategy for each.

2. Use Signaling Effectively

Your positioning can send strong signals about your product and intentions.

Example: Positioning as a premium brand can signal quality and justify higher prices.

3. Look for Win-Win Opportunities

Not all competitive situations are zero-sum. Look for positioning strategies that grow the overall market.

Idea: Can you position your product in a way that complements, rather than directly compete with, existing solutions?

4. Anticipate and Prepare for Competitor Responses

Use game theory to predict how competitors might respond to your positioning and prepare counter-moves.

Exercise: Run regular “war games” with your team to simulate competitor responses.

5. Be Prepared to Pivot

The market is dynamic. Your initial positioning may need to evolve as the competitive landscape changes.

Personal Lesson: I once had to rapidly reposition a product when a major competitor unexpectedly entered our market. Flexibility is key.

Challenges and Limitations

While game theory is a powerful tool for product positioning, it’s not without its challenges:

1. Incomplete Information: In the real world, we often don’t have full information about competitor strategies or market conditions.
2. Irrational Actors: Game theory assumes rational decision-making, but humans (and companies) aren’t always rational.
3. Complexity: Real-world markets are often more complex than even the most sophisticated game theory models.
4. Dynamic Environment: Market conditions can change rapidly, making it difficult to maintain a stable equilibrium.
5. Overreliance on Theory: It’s crucial to balance game theory insights with real-world data and customer feedback.

Future Trends

As we look to the future, I see several exciting trends in the application of game theory to product positioning:

1. AI and Machine Learning: Advanced algorithms will enable more sophisticated modeling of competitive dynamics.
2. Real-Time Positioning Adjustments: Digital platforms will allow for more dynamic, real-time positioning based on competitor actions and market feedback.
3. Ecosystem Positioning: As products become more interconnected, positioning will increasingly focus on entire ecosystems rather than individual products.
4. Ethical Considerations: There will be a growing emphasis on using game theory to create value for customers, not just to outmaneuver competitors.
5. Integration with Behavioral Economics: Combining game theory with insights from behavioral economics will lead to more nuanced positioning strategies.

Conclusion

As we’ve explored throughout this post, game theory offers a powerful framework for approaching competitive product positioning. By thinking strategically about competitor actions, market dynamics, and long-term outcomes, we can develop more robust and effective positioning strategies.

Remember, the goal isn’t to “win” at all costs but to find a sustainable position that creates value for your customers and your business. Game theory is a tool to help us think more clearly about complex competitive situations, not a prescription for cutthroat tactics.

As product managers, our job is to navigate the complex, ever-changing seas of the market. Game theory is like a sophisticated compass and map combined – it won’t steer the ship for us, but it can help us chart a much smarter course.

I encourage you to start incorporating game theory thinking into your product positioning process. Begin with simple exercises, like mapping out competitor responses to your strategies, or considering the long-term equilibrium of your market. Over time, you’ll develop a more nuanced understanding of your competitive landscape and how to position your product for success.

Remember, in the game of product management, the real win is creating products that genuinely solve problems and delight users. Use game theory as a tool to help you get there, but never lose sight of the real goal: making something truly valuable.

---

If you enjoyed this post on Game theory for product positioning, you may also like:

• How to Craft a High-Impact Pricing Strategy
• Guerrilla User Research Tactics on a Tight Budget
• Organizational Ambidexterity in Product Portfolio Management
• Impact Mismatch: Avoiding the Pitfalls of Overconfidence and Mismatched Expectations