Beyond the Backlog

If you’re a frequent reader of Beyond the Backlog, it’s likely that you’ve already had to skim through posts of more methodologies, frameworks, and metrics than you can shake a stick at. But every once in a while, something comes along that truly shifts the paradigm. Today, I want to introduce you to one such game-changer: the Value Innovation Index.

---

---

In product management, we’re constantly searching for ways to measure and enhance the value we deliver to our customers while maintaining a competitive edge. Traditional metrics like revenue, market share, and customer satisfaction are undoubtedly important, but they often fall short in capturing the full picture of innovation and value creation.

Enter the Value Innovation Index – a powerful tool that’s revolutionizing how we think about and measure the impact of our product decisions. In this post, I’ll explore what the Value Innovation Index is, how to calculate and interpret it, and most importantly, how you can leverage it to supercharge your product management strategy.

What is the Value Innovation Index?

The Value Innovation Index (VII) is a comprehensive metric that quantifies the balance between the value a product delivers to customers and the level of innovation it brings to the market. It’s not just another number to track – it’s a paradigm shift in how we evaluate the success and potential of our products.

At its core, the Value Innovation Index is built on the principle that sustainable success in product management comes from creating a leap in value for both buyers and the company itself. This concept, originally introduced by W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne in their Blue Ocean Strategy, emphasizes the importance of breaking out of the traditional competitive landscape (the “red ocean”) and creating uncontested market space (the “blue ocean”).

The VII takes this concept further by providing a quantifiable measure of how well a product achieves this balance. It’s not just about being innovative for innovation’s sake, nor is it about simply meeting customer needs. The real magic happens when you can do both simultaneously – and that’s exactly what the Value Innovation Index helps us measure and strive for.

The Components of the Value Innovation Index

To truly understand the Value Innovation Index, we need to break it down into its core components. The VII is composed of two primary elements:

1. Customer Value Score (CVS)
2. Innovation Potential Score (IPS)

Let’s examine each of these in detail:

Customer Value Score (CVS)

The Customer Value Score measures how well your product meets and exceeds customer expectations. It takes into account factors such as:

• User satisfaction
• Problem-solution fit
• Price-to-value ratio
• Customer retention rates
• Net Promoter Score (NPS)

To calculate the CVS, we aggregate these factors using a weighted scoring system. The weights can be adjusted based on your specific industry and product type, but here’s a general framework I often use:

• User satisfaction: 30%
• Problem-solution fit: 25%
• Price-to-value ratio: 20%
• Customer retention rates: 15%
• Net Promoter Score: 10%

Each factor is rated on a scale of 1-10, then multiplied by its weight to get a final score out of 100.

Innovation Potential Score (IPS)

The Innovation Potential Score assesses how innovative your product is compared to existing solutions in the market. It considers aspects such as:

• Technological advancement
• Market disruption potential
• Scalability
• Sustainability
• Intellectual property strength

Similar to the CVS, we use a weighted scoring system for the IPS:

• Technological advancement: 30%
• Market disruption potential: 25%
• Scalability: 20%
• Sustainability: 15%
• Intellectual property strength: 10%

Again, each factor is rated on a scale of 1-10 and then weighted to get a score out of 100.

By combining these two scores, we get a holistic view of both the value we’re delivering to customers and the innovative potential of our product. This combination is what makes the Value Innovation Index so powerful – it ensures we’re not just innovating for the sake of innovation, but doing so in a way that truly benefits our customers and creates new market opportunities.

In the next section, I’ll walk you through how to calculate the Value Innovation Index using these components. But before we dive into the math, I want to emphasize that the real power of the VII lies not just in the final number, but in the insights we gain from each component of the calculation process.

How to Calculate the Value Innovation Index

Now that we understand the components of the Value Innovation Index, let’s dive into how to calculate it. The process might seem a bit complex at first, but I promise it’s worth the effort. Here’s a step-by-step guide:

1. Calculate the Customer Value Score (CVS)
   • Rate each factor (user satisfaction, problem-solution fit, etc.) on a scale of 1-10
   • Multiply each rating by its corresponding weight
   • Sum up all the weighted scores to get a total out of 100
2. Calculate the Innovation Potential Score (IPS)
   • Rate each factor (technological advancement, market disruption potential, etc.) on a scale of 1-10
   • Multiply each rating by its corresponding weight
   • Sum up all the weighted scores to get a total out of 100
3. Calculate the Value Innovation Index (VII)
   • The VII is the geometric mean of the CVS and IPS
   • Formula: VII = √(CVS * IPS)

Let’s walk through an example to make this clearer:

Imagine we’re evaluating a new AI-powered project management tool. After careful analysis, we’ve come up with the following scores:

Customer Value Score (CVS):

• User satisfaction: 8 * 0.30 = 2.4
• Problem-solution fit: 9 * 0.25 = 2.25
• Price-to-value ratio: 7 * 0.20 = 1.4
• Customer retention rates: 8 * 0.15 = 1.2
• Net Promoter Score: 8 * 0.10 = 0.8

Total CVS = 2.4 + 2.25 + 1.4 + 1.2 + 0.8 = 80

Innovation Potential Score (IPS):

• Technological advancement: 9 * 0.30 = 2.7
• Market disruption potential: 8 * 0.25 = 2
• Scalability: 9 * 0.20 = 1.8
• Sustainability: 7 * 0.15 = 1.05
• Intellectual property strength: 8 * 0.10 = 0.8

Total IPS = 2.7 + 2 + 1.8 + 1.05 + 0.8 = 83.5

Now, let’s calculate the Value Innovation Index:

VII = √(80 * 83.5) ≈ 81.73

This gives us a Value Innovation Index of 81.73 out of a possible 100.

Interpreting the Value Innovation Index

Now that we have our Value Innovation Index, what does it actually mean? How do we interpret this number to drive our product decisions? Here’s my framework for understanding VII scores:

• 90-100: Exceptional. Your product is not only meeting customer needs at an extremely high level but also pushing the boundaries of innovation in your industry. This is blue ocean territory.
• 80-89: Excellent. You’re delivering great value to customers and have strong innovative elements. There’s still room for improvement, but you’re on the right track.
• 70-79: Good. Your product is solid, delivering value and showing innovation, but there’s significant room for improvement in both areas.
• 60-69: Average. You’re meeting basic customer needs and showing some innovation, but you’re at risk of being outperformed by competitors.
• Below 60: Needs improvement. Your product is underperforming in terms of both customer value and innovation. Immediate action is required to avoid obsolescence.

Remember, the power of the VII isn’t just in the final score, but in the insights you gain from each component. If your CVS is significantly higher than your IPS, it might indicate that while your product is meeting current customer needs well, it’s at risk of disruption from more innovative competitors. Conversely, if your IPS is much higher than your CVS, you might be innovating in ways that aren’t translating to customer value.

In our example above, with a VII of 81.73, our AI-powered project management tool is performing excellently. It’s delivering strong customer value (CVS of 80) and showing even stronger innovation potential (IPS of 83.5). However, there’s still room for improvement, particularly in areas like the price-to-value ratio and sustainability.

Applying the Value Innovation Index in Product Management

Now that we understand what the Value Innovation Index is and how to calculate it, let’s explore how we can apply it in our day-to-day work as product managers. Here are some key ways I’ve found the VII to be invaluable:

1. Prioritizing Features and Initiatives Use the VII to evaluate potential new features or product initiatives. By calculating a projected VII for each option, you can prioritize those that offer the best balance of customer value and innovation.
2. Competitive Analysis Calculate the VII for your competitors’ products (to the best of your ability) and compare them to your own. This can help you identify areas where you’re falling behind or where you have a competitive advantage.
3. Product Roadmap Planning Use the VII to guide your long-term product strategy. Aim to have a mix of initiatives that will boost both your CVS and IPS over time.
4. Performance Tracking Regularly calculate your product’s VII and track it over time. This can help you measure the impact of your product decisions and identify trends in your product’s performance.
5. Team Alignment The VII provides a common language and metric for discussing product strategy across your organization. It can help align your team around the dual goals of customer value and innovation.
6. Investor Communications For startups and growing companies, the VII can be a powerful metric to communicate your product’s potential to investors, going beyond traditional metrics like revenue or user growth.

Remember, the goal isn’t to obsess over achieving a perfect 100 VII. Instead, use it as a tool to drive balanced, strategic thinking about your product. In the next section, we’ll look at some real-world case studies of how companies have used the Value Innovation Index to drive success.

Case Studies: Value Innovation Index in Action

To appreciate the power of the Value Innovation Index, let’s look at some real-world examples of how it’s been applied. While these are anonymized for confidentiality, they’re based on real experiences I’ve had or observed in the industry.

Case Study 1: The E-commerce Platform Revamp

A mid-sized e-commerce company was struggling to differentiate itself in a crowded market. Their initial VII calculation showed a score of 65, with a CVS of 70 and an IPS of 60. This indicated that while they were meeting basic customer needs, they weren’t innovating enough to stand out.

The product team used these insights to drive a platform revamp. They focused on introducing AI-powered personalized recommendations and a revolutionary one-click checkout process. Six months after implementation, their VII had risen to 78, with both CVS and IPS showing significant improvements.

Key Takeaway: The VII helped identify the need for innovation and guided the direction of the revamp, resulting in a more competitive product.

Case Study 2: The Project Management Tool Pivot

A startup had developed a project management tool that, while technologically advanced, wasn’t gaining traction in the market. Their initial VII was 72, but interestingly, their IPS was 85 while their CVS was only 61.

This discrepancy highlighted that while they were innovating, they weren’t delivering value that resonated with customers. The team used this insight to pivot their product strategy, focusing more on user experience and integrations with popular tools.

A year later, their VII had increased to 84, with a much more balanced CVS of 82 and IPS of 86. More importantly, their user base had grown significantly, and they were now profitable.

Key Takeaway: The VII can reveal misalignments between innovation efforts and customer value, guiding strategic pivots.

Case Study 3: The Enterprise Software Evolution

A large enterprise software company was losing market share to more agile competitors. Their VII had been steadily declining over the years, reaching a low of 58 (CVS: 65, IPS: 52).

Using the VII as a north star metric, they embarked on a multi-year transformation. They invested heavily in cloud infrastructure, AI capabilities, and a more user-friendly interface. They also introduced a modular product structure that allowed for more customization.

Three years into the transformation, their VII had risen to 76, with balanced improvements in both CVS and IPS. They had successfully defended their market position and were once again seen as an industry leader.

Key Takeaway: The VII can guide long-term strategic transformations, helping established companies remain competitive.

Challenges and Limitations of the Value Innovation Index

While the Value Innovation Index is a powerful tool, it’s important to acknowledge its challenges and limitations:

1. Subjectivity in Scoring: The scoring of individual factors can be subjective, potentially leading to biased results. It’s crucial to have a diverse team involved in the scoring process and to regularly calibrate your scoring criteria.
2. Industry Specificity: The weights and factors that make up the CVS and IPS may need to be adjusted for different industries. What constitutes innovation in fintech might be very different from innovation in healthcare.
3. Short-term vs. Long-term Balance: The VII might not always capture the tension between short-term customer satisfaction and long-term innovation. Sometimes, truly revolutionary innovations might initially score low on customer value.
4. Quantifying Innovation: Innovation, by its nature, can be difficult to quantify. The IPS does its best to capture this, but it’s an inherently challenging aspect to measure.
5. External Factors: The VII focuses on product-specific factors and might not fully capture external influences like market conditions, regulatory environment, or competitor actions.
6. Resource Intensity: Properly calculating and tracking the VII requires significant time and effort. For small teams or early-stage startups, this might be a challenge.

Despite these limitations, I’ve found that the benefits of using the VII far outweigh the challenges. The key is to use it as one tool in your product management toolkit, not as the sole driver of decisions.

Best Practices for Implementing the Value Innovation Index

Based on my experience implementing the VII across various organizations, here are some best practices I’ve developed:

1. Start with a Pilot: Begin by calculating the VII for a single product or feature. This allows you to refine your process before rolling it out more broadly.
2. Calibrate Regularly: Regularly review and adjust your scoring criteria to ensure consistency across products and over time.
3. Cross-functional Input: Involve team members from different functions (engineering, design, marketing, sales) in the scoring process. This provides a more holistic view of both customer value and innovation potential.
4. Automate Where Possible: Look for ways to automate data collection for some of the factors, especially those related to customer value (e.g., NPS, retention rates).
5. Combine with Other Metrics: Use the VII in conjunction with other key metrics like revenue, user growth, and market share for a complete picture of product performance.
6. Communicate Clearly: Ensure all stakeholders understand what the VII means and how it’s calculated. Transparency is key to buy-in.
7. Set Realistic Targets: Don’t aim for a perfect 100. Set realistic improvement targets based on your current score and market position.
8. Regular Review Cycles: Implement regular (quarterly or bi-annual) VII review cycles to track progress and adjust strategy.

Conclusion

The Value Innovation Index is more than just another metric – it’s a mindset shift. It pushes us as product managers to constantly balance meeting current customer needs with pushing the boundaries of what’s possible. It challenges us to think beyond incremental improvements and strive for true value innovation.

Implementing the VII has transformed my approach to product management. It’s helped me make more balanced decisions, communicate more effectively with stakeholders, and ultimately, create products that not only meet customer needs but also shape the future of our industry.

I encourage you to start small, experiment with the VII in your own context, and see how it can transform your product management practice. The future of product management lies in this balance of value and innovation – and the Value Innovation Index is our compass in navigating this exciting terrain.

---

If you found this post on the Value Innovation Index, you may also like:

• The Buyer Utility Map: Unlocking Customer Value in Product Management
• Platform Economics: Network Effects and Multi-Sided Markets in Product Strategy
• Adopting a Moonshot Mindset – Managing Anti-Fragile Products